MONEY THOUGHT:

Why ‘Free’ Is Costing You More Than You Think

Raise your hand if you’ve ever been swayed into making a purchase because it got you something for free. Adding something extra to an online cart in order to unlock free shipping, getting a free mini product with purchase, buying a certain item of food after a free sample, or even Buy-One-Get-One free. Don’t even get me started on free trials on subscriptions.

My hand is up in the air.

I’ll confess! I’ve timed my Ulta Beauty purchases (I have skin the color of provolone cheese – I spend a lot on sunscreen) in order to get some free lip products. And half of the stuff I buy at Trader Joe’s is because I tasted it at their free-sample counter (sadly, a casualty of COVID. RIP). There is something about the word “free” that makes our lizard brain lick its own eyeball in delight. Let’s talk about it.

The Zero Price Effect

Behavioral economist Dan Ariely spent years proving what we all secretly know — slap a “FREE” label on something and our rational decision-making leaves the chat. In his iconic “Zero as a Special Price” research, participants chose between two chocolates: the Swiss masterpiece that is a Lindt truffle for 13 cents, or a free Hershey’s Kiss. Over twice as many people grabbed the free Hershey’s Kiss, despite it being trash chocolate… and if you disagree, you can go argue with a wall.

Then Ariely and his team ran the same experiment, but this time they charged 1 penny for the Kiss and raised the price of the Lindt by one cent. Suddenly, everyone came to their senses, and the Lindt was back on top. Almost 4 times as many participants chose the 14-cent Lindt over the 1-cent Kiss.

The price difference did not change, but the decisions sure did.

Researchers ran similar experiments with real chocolates and pictures of chocolates, and the results were similar every time. The conclusion? When things are free, our brains overvalue them and lead us to make irrational decisions. Using logic, we know it’s crazypants to freely choose an item that’s lesser than its alternative. But because one involved money and the other did not, study participants saw the free item as having only an upside.

An acquired taste

I’ve only had the pleasure of experiencing Costco in-store sampling once, but it’s a memory that my brain decided is important enough to hold on to. There is just something about eating barely bite-sized squares of pizza off a napkin while pushing a shopping cart with the other hand that hits just right.

Companies spend ~$2 billion a year on free samples — and a single sampling event at a grocery store runs $150–$340 a day. That’s not generosity. That’s a calculated chess move. And the return-on-investment is even sweeter than that wine sample you just sipped.

  • When Ziploc sampled a new space bag at Costco, sales jumped 156%
  • Beer, wine, cheese, and frozen pizza have seen sales increases ranging from 71% to 600% after sampling events
  • Per a BYU study, sampling one brand even lifts sales for competing brands nearby — a rising tide of free stuff floats all boats

But here’s the sneaky part: It’s not just familiarity that makes samples work so well. It’s guilt. Ahh!!! Receiving something free triggers that same irrational warm-and-fuzzy feeling as the Hershey’s Kiss — plus a bonus layer of social obligation. You took their little sample. Now you feel like you owe them.

Free Shipping

Oh, you thought stores offered free shipping because they’re nice? Nah. Ariely says shipping costs hit different than product costs because we’re wired to pay for things, but paying for the journey to get that thing to us feels unfair. A shipping fee makes the whole purchase feel like a rip-off, even if the total price is totally reasonable. Remove that “unfair” charge, and suddenly we’re one-click purchasing like it’s our job.

A 2019 survey of 1,600 shoppers found that 77% said free shipping made them more likely to pull the trigger on an online purchase. Even more wild? Former Wharton professor David Bell found that shoppers actively chose to save $6.99 on shipping over saving $10 on the actual product. That math ain’t mathing, babe.

In its early days, Amazon rolled out free shipping across several European countries — except France, where they charged one franc (basically a penny). Free shipping countries saw dramatic increases in sales. France? Barely moved.

The bottom line: Nearly free is not the same as free. Your brain knows the difference, and retailers absolutely know your brain knows the difference.

Every rule has an exception

A free sample of a thing, we will pay for. A free sample of online content? Not so much. Handing out free bites of brie at Costco works because you already know aproximately what cheese costs. But so much internet content is free that our brains have filed online media under “should always be free,” making a paywall feel like a personal attack.

Because content has been free online for so long, a monthly subscription feels wildly expensive for “just one more article” — even if you’d spend that same amount on a single iced latte without blinking

Per the Reuters Institute’s 2020 Digital News Report, only ~20% of Americans actually pay for online news. A stubborn ~40% say they would never pay for news. Full stop. Not negotiating.

Think about Facebook. Or Instagram. Or TikTok. Almost no one would willingly pay for social media now, even though we technically “pay” for it every time an ad convinces us to buy something we didn’t need.

But the thing is, free isn’t always the better deal here. Free sites run more ads, and those ads are painfully good at getting us to spend money. The “free” version of the internet might actually cost the most, in the long run.

Why you should care (for free!)

Isn’t it fun to realize that “free” might actually be one of the most expensive things?! Every free sample, free shipping offer, free article, and free app is a door that you’re opening to a very smart, very well-funded team of researchers who have studied exactly how your brain works and designed an experience to get you to spend. They’ve literally read (or written!) the same studies we just talked about. They did their homework. The question is: did you?

The zero price effect isn’t a character flaw: it’s human wiring. But knowing this means you can catch yourself before that “free gift with purchase” costs you $100. Small, “free”-influenced purchases are the sneaky budget leaks that never show up on anyone’s financial plan — but absolutely show up in your bank statement.

Start asking one question before any “free” offer reels you in: would I make this same choice if the word “free” wasn’t involved? If the answer is no — that’s your sign, darling.

Now, go unsubscribe from something. You know the one.

Continue reading

You’ll like these ramblings on money too:

The End Is Near

The End Is Near

It’s December. We are so close to closing the book on 2022 and I am not cool with this. Where did...

Search blog posts:

Wisconsin CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional and educator Sarah Paulson

THE AUTHOR

Meet Sarah Paulson, your
CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™

Although I’m a born-and-raised Wisconsinite – living in Appleton, Wisconsin –

I consider myself more of a world citizen.

True story: once when going through international customs in Amsterdam, the officers asked why they couldn’t find a Dutch residency permit in my American passport.

I bring a big world picture to my money management advice so you can view the wider world, too.

All written content on this site is for information purposes only.
Opinions expressed herein are solely those of Valkyrie Financial, unless otherwise specifically cited.

Read full disclaimer →

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This