MONEY THOUGHT:

My Stuff is Better Than Your Stuff – The Endowment Effect

The Endowment Effect (or, the Divestiture Aversion, if you wanna get really fancy) might be one of the most deeply human things about us. It’s the tendency to value something more highly simply because it’s ours. 

The most obvious example shows up when buying or selling a home: sellers will believe they deserve the highest price the neighborhood has ever seen and, buyers will go “lol, what??” But we can also feel this way about the mystery box in the attic that’s survived three moves without ever once being opened. Or that old t-shirt that has so many holes in the fabric, it’s more like a spiderweb than a garment. But we just can’t seem to let it go.

Deep down, we know it’s just stuff. And yet the second someone tries to take it off our hands? Suddenly we’re negotiating like it’s a hostage situation.

The mug study

In a 1990 study from the University of Chicago, researchers gave half a group of students a coffee mug. Just a regular mug, exactly the same kind that could be bought down at the campus store for a fixed price. It didn’t even come with coffee in it! Everyone knew what it was worth.

But when it came time for the mug-havers to sell their ceramic receptacle to the mug-less, they demanded more than the store price. Nothing changed about the mugs. (Again, no one filled their mug with coffee.) What changed was that it was theirs.

The researchers determined that ownership messes with our brains. Whether it’s a mug, a stock, or a home, the second something is ours, it becomes more valuable to us. We price in a premium, just because. 

OMG, why are we like this?

Like most things involving the wild and wacky human brain, there isn’t a clear-cut answer. But it’s probably not really about the thing itself. There’s something about the feelings, memories, and associations tied to the thing.

When it’s time to sell, our brains don’t focus on the money gained. They think about the memories lost. Nerds call this Loss Aversion.

Our prehistoric lizard brains learned that focusing on negative outcomes was the best way to avoid being eaten by saber-tooth tigers, and we haven’t outgrown that mental programming. So a loss of anything will almost always feel bigger than gaining the equivalent in cash.

This is why parting with our things feels less like a transaction and more like a goodbye.

An opposing theory says it’s not about the loss, it’s about the Ownership Identity.

A 2009 study re-ran the mug study but with a twist: some of the potential mug buyers already had the same mug at home. And those buyers were still willing to pay the above market price sellers were asking.

The team determined that study participants weren’t being driven by loss aversion, but by attachment. That owning something rewires how connected you feel to it.

Or maybe it has nothing to do with feelings at all. We’re all just really bad at putting a price on things, according to the Reference Price Theory.

This theory says we’re all anchoring to totally different benchmarks. Sellers look at the best comparable sale. Buyers look at the cheapest acceptable option. Nobody’s being irrational — we’re just running different math from different starting lines.

But I need to do like Elsa and let it go

Whatever the reason for the Endowment Effect, the feelings are very real. Working through them calls for acknowledging the weight of attachment and shifting the framework.

Put yourself in your future shoes. If you didn’t already own it, would you buy it at today’s price? How you came to own something isn’t a good enough reason to continue owning it, bb.

Give the feelings a new home. Research has found that feelings can be transferred from one object to another. And a photograph or a trinket take up a lot less space than most objects.

Ask what the feelings are protecting. What do you think you’ll lose if you let a thing go? Maybe there is grief or fear, maybe even an identity that is tied to the thing.

In the end, the endowment effect isn’t a problem to solve. It comes from love, memory, and the human need for our choices to mean something. The goal isn’t to strip that away, just to create a little space between the feeling and the decision — enough to ask whether the price in your head reflects the world as it is, or the world as you remember it. And sometimes the answer is simply I’m keeping it. That’s allowed too. If you’re facing one of these decisions — a home, a business, an investment, anything worth more than money — let’s talk it through. Not to argue you out of how you feel, but because the feeling and the math are both real.

Continue reading

You’ll like these ramblings on money too:

Search blog posts:

Wisconsin CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional and educator Sarah Paulson

THE AUTHOR

Meet Sarah Paulson, your
CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™

Although I’m a born-and-raised Wisconsinite – living in Appleton, Wisconsin –

I consider myself more of a world citizen.

True story: once when going through international customs in Amsterdam, the officers asked why they couldn’t find a Dutch residency permit in my American passport.

I bring a big world picture to my money management advice so you can view the wider world, too.

All written content on this site is for information purposes only.
Opinions expressed herein are solely those of Valkyrie Financial, unless otherwise specifically cited.

Read full disclaimer →

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This